6 Jan – MBS Alumni Toastmaster Club – The Secret to a Meaningful Evaluation
Do you remember the best, or the worst, feedback you ever received? What made it remarkable?
We evaluate, give and receive feedback at work everyday.
According to TED speaker LeeAnn Renninger, a study showed that only 26% of workers remembered & felt feedback improved their work performance.
This low figure is because the feedback given was not brain friendly enough. It was either too soft and indirect so the brain did not recognise it or was confused; or it was too aggressive, direct and critical and the brain shut-down, sensing an attack & turned to defence mode.
To give great feedback she suggests we:
1. Ask a short or important question at the beginning which requires an answer (to let the respondent’s brain get ready to start)
2. Give specific points with examples (instead of a vague statement)
3. Elaborate the feedback by highlighting its impact
4.End with a question such as: What are your thoughts on this? Do you see it?
After discussion among ourselves, we generated these insights:
1.Don’t give all feedback in one-go
2.Give critical feedback privately
3.Use storytelling when talking to seniors
4.Avoid sensitive issues & cultural taboos
5.Control stress and temper
Give ACCLAIM to Pappu and Jason who took up these two important meeting roles for the first time - Toastmaster of the Evening and Table Topics Master - respectively. Well done, guys!
Evaluation_20210106.jpg
Evaluation

 

Manchester Business School